Whey protein concentrate vs isolate vs hydrolysate: marketing hype vs real science

Contrary to popular assumption, whey protein concentrate, isolate, and hydrolysate are not three tiers of quality. They are three levels of processing.

TL;DR

Multiple whey types exist because they solve different constraints: digestive tolerance, dietary restrictions, budget limits, and clinical needs.

On paper, total protein intake matters far more than protein form - differences between whey types rarely change outcomes like muscle gain, recovery, or body composition, in theory.

In practice, however, people don’t fail because of theory. They fail because of constraints like lactose tolerance, calorie ceilings, appetite suppression, budget trade-offs, and marketing distortions.

The rest of this article lets you evaluate your own needs and profile, so choosing the right whey protein is driven by confidence, not guesswork.

Getting clear on the terminology 

What do the terms ‘concentrate’, ‘isolate’, and ‘hydrolyzed whey’ actually mean?

Whey protein concentrate (WPC) typically contains 70–80 percent protein by weight, delivering roughly 2–3 grams of lactose and a small amount of fat per serving (see table 1), as well as some bioactive fractions.

While multiple forms of WPC exist, the rest of this article refers to WPC-80, the most widely available commercial form of whey protein concentrate.

Whey protein isolate (WPI) contains at least 90 percent protein by weight, and delivers less than 1 gram of lactose per serving in most WPI products. The amino acid profile remains the same as concentrate, but the protein is more calorie-dense.

Thus, hydrolyzed whey is not higher-quality protein. It is protein processed differently by the body.

Table 1

Typical nutrient composition and protein delivery of different forms of whey protein supplement

Is isolate the only safe form for lactose intolerant individuals?

The European Food Safety Authority’s review of lactose intolerance found that most adults, including those who are lactose intolerant, can safely ingest up to 12 grams of lactose in a single dose with minimal symptoms.

The typical 2 to 3 grams of lactose per serving in WPC is far below this level. This implies that WPI’s lower lactose content is really a meaningful and necessary upgrade only for those with severe lactose intolerance.

Given the lack of precise estimates, experts peg this at less than half of those with self-reported lactose malabsorption who make up 36% of the US population.

Hydrolyzed whey: What’s behind the hype? 

Hydrolyzed whey protein is often marketed as “superior absorption”, a term that obscures rather than explains the real distinction between hydrolysate aka hydrolyzed whey (WPH) and standard WPC forms.

Hydrolyzed whey does lead to faster amino acid appearance in the bloodstream. But the claim that WPH reduces gastrointestinal distress is extrapolated from infant formula research. 

Studies of healthy adults report no difference in the GI tolerance of WPH compared to whey concentrate.

Critically, resistance training research has so far found no advantage for WPH over other whey supplements (WPC or WPI) in terms of muscle gain, improved strength or recovery time, although all whey supplements yielded superior gains compared to a placebo condition. 

WPH may represent an advantage for individuals with clinical levels of GI distress, for example during post-surgical recovery or in cases of allergic reactions to intact milk proteins. However, note that there is no direct evidence to date supporting this reasoning.

Does whey type affect acne or hormones? 

Evidence clearly shows that whey intake correlates with acne eruptions and acne aggravation in some users, thought to result from an increase in insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1). 

Although some supplement users try to seek relief from their symptoms by switching between whey forms, there is no evidence at present to suggest that whey type (WPC, WPI, WPH) affects acne differently. Given that IGF-1 responses are driven primarily by amino acid composition, there is little reason to expect that ongoing research will uncover such differences, either.

Total protein intake and individual sensitivity matter more than the processing behind the whey supplement.

In the last decade, science has successfully dismantled the myth about whey protein supplements affecting sex hormones: studies examining whether whey supplements affect androgens and estradiol over both short-term and long-term use have failed to find appreciable increases or decreases in body hormone levels.

The ‘leucine’ angle: Lab tests vs real-world outcomes 

A frequently cited advantage of whey isolate is its higher leucine concentration per gram of protein. On paper, this difference is real. Whey isolate delivers roughly 20 percent more leucine per gram than a typical concentrate formulation like WPC-80.

After reviewing a huge number of studies comparing the impact of different forms of protein, the International Society of Sports Nutrition position stand article clarified that adequate protein dose is the only important factor influencing muscle protein synthesis (MPS) and improved exercise strength.

What this means for whey supplement users is that either WPC or WPI can translate to equivalent gains in MPS, exercise strength and recovery time, provided consistency of intake and training.

Related: Casein vs whey protein: Which is better for your goals?

Where isolate makes a real difference 

In terms of protein quality indexed by the Digestible Indispensable Amino Acid Score (DIAAS), WPI does show a modest but measurable advantage (see Table 2).

Table 2

DIAAS scores for different protein supplements

*A score >1.0 is considered high-quality protein.

WPI’s higher DIAAS of 1.09 reflects its superior digestibility and amino acid delivery per gram.

Where this may matter most: When appetite is low but protein needs are elevated (for example, in some but not all elderly adults with sarcopenia), WPI can help bridge the gap between required protein intake and reduced appetite.

Another relevant context is that of competitive athletes or other individuals with highly specific caloric intake goals. Where meal sizes are constrained, yet protein quantity must be achieved, higher protein density per calorie becomes meaningful.

Note that athlete-endorsed and NSF-certified brands currently sell exclusively WPI products.

Which whey does the economics point? 

A comprehensive survey of popular whey protein supplements in the US market turned up several surprising insights: 

• Consumers pay 30–100% premiums for whey isolate (WPI) and hydrolyzed (WPH) products over concentrate (WPC), in spite of the thin research (only two head-to-head RCTs to date!) directly comparing whey forms (see Table 3).

• Pure WPC products are surprisingly rare: Only two of the nine brands in our survey offered 100% concentrate, while the rest were blends.

• NSF-certified and athletic brands exclusively sell WPI, representing the highest price tier; products cost as much as 2x the price of budget WPC brands

• Despite premium pricing the true protein content of WPI brands surveyed varied dramatically, from as low as 69.5% to 89.7%

• Only one true WPH product was identified among the brands in our survey

Table 3

Approximate cost across concentrate, isolate and hydrolyzed whey protein supplements

Clearly, concentrate (WPC) represents the lowest cost per gram of protein while delivering comparable fitness and GI outcomes for most healthy, adult users. 

The premium pricing of most isolate (WPI) products is justifiable when it resolves a real constraint (lactose intolerance, calorie control).

Whey hydrolysate (WPH) has the narrowest use case, besides being the most expensive.

Related: Hemp vs whey protein: How to choose without bloating, breakouts, or disappointment

Next steps: Simplifying the decision 

The table below should help you decide on the best fit for your health and fitness needs.

Table 4

Typical ‘best fit’ between whey protein forms

*Best consumed under medical supervision

Try out our clean, high-quality protein powders and see for yourself why hundreds of women have made the switch to Nutranelle. To get a surprise deal on your first purchase, and exclusive, insider-only perks, drop your email in the form below.